Magic Mill vs Cosori Dehydrator: An In-Depth Comparison for Home Food Preservation

Welcome to the world of home food preservation, a realm where fresh fruits, vegetables, and meats transform into long-lasting, nutrient-dense snacks. Imagine the magic of creating your own beef jerky, fruit leathers, or dried herbs. With the Magic Mill and Cosori food dehydrators, this magic comes alive in your kitchen. Both bring a unique blend of features and performance, but which one is the best fit for you? Let’s dive in and explore the Magic Mill vs Cosori dehydrator comparison.

No1 Top Selling Food Dehydrator on Amazon (Over 16,000 Reviews)
$159.99 ($159.99 / Count)
No1 Top Selling Food Dehydrator on Amazon (Over 16,000 Reviews)
03/14/2024 07:39 am GMT

Key Takeaways

  • This comparison provides an overview of the Magic Mill and Cosori dehydrators, outlining their different designs and functionalities to help home food preservation enthusiasts make informed purchase decisions.
  • Key features compared include drying capacity, temperature range & control, noise level performance & efficiency.
  • User reviews provide valuable information about a product’s performance, usability and features for potential buyers to consider when assessing value for money.

Overview: Magic Mill and Cosori Dehydrators

Food dehydrators, by dehydrating food and removing moisture, serve as potent tools for healthier eating and sustainable living. They play a crucial role in preventing bacterial growth, extending food shelf life, and enhancing taste. The Magic Mill and Cosori are reputable brands offering some of the best food dehydrators on the market, including the highly efficient food dehydrator machine. These machines can make snacks like fruit leather and beef jerky at home, providing a healthier and more affordable alternative to store-bought snacks.

Despite sharing the ability to heat up to a maximum of 145 degrees Fahrenheit, the design and functionalities of the Magic Mill and Cosori dehydrators differ, giving rise to distinct user experiences. This in-depth comparison aims to provide a comprehensive analysis for home food preservation enthusiasts, taking you a step closer to making an informed purchase decision.

Magic Mill Food Dehydrator

Close-up of even drying in Magic Mill Food Dehydrator

The Magic Mill Food Dehydrator is a powerhouse in the realm of food dehydration. It offers:

  • Uniform drying process
  • Intuitive interface
  • Transparent doors for easy monitoring of the drying process
  • Mesh trays and nonstick trays for versatility in drying different types of foods

This machine is a versatile choice for any kitchen.

With its horizontal flow design, the Magic Mill Dehydrator offers the following benefits:

  • Uniform heat exposure for all trays, minimizing flavor mixing between foods and preventing juices from dripping into the heating element
  • Metal trays that are durable and easy to clean
  • A popular choice among many users

However, it may take slightly longer to reach the desired temperature settings compared to other models.

Cosori Food Dehydrator

On the other side of the ring, we have the Cosori Food Dehydrator. This dehydrator stands out with its:

  • Compact design
  • Stylish black and stainless steel finish
  • Glass door
  • User-friendly digital control panel

It is easy to operate, making it a favorite among users who prefer a blend of simplicity and efficiency.

The Cosori Food Dehydrator offers the following features:

  • Flexible temperature range from 95°F to 165°F, facilitating the optimal drying of diverse food types
  • Customization to your dehydration process
  • Noise level similar to that of regular conversation or background music, ensuring minimal disruption during the food dehydration process.

Key Features Comparison

Let’s further explore the distinct features of these dehydrators. When it comes to drying capacity, a crucial aspect to consider is the number of trays a dehydrator has. A greater number of trays mean more food can be dehydrated at once, saving you time and energy. While the Cosori Food Dehydrator is equipped with six stainless steel trays, the Magic Mill Food Dehydrator’s capacity depends on the specific model, with some models offering up to nine trays.

Another key feature to consider is temperature control. The Magic Mill provides a range of 95 to 158 degrees Fahrenheit, suitable for drying a variety of foods. On the other hand, the Cosori Dehydrator offers:

  • A variable temperature range between 95 and 165 degrees Fahrenheit
  • Allows for operations up to 48 hours
  • Provides users with the flexibility to effectively dehydrate a variety of foods.

Drying Capacity

The functionality of a food dehydrator can be significantly influenced by its drying capacity. The Magic Mill Dehydrator offers a generous drying space, allowing you to dry a substantial amount of food simultaneously. On the other hand, the Cosori Food Dehydrator comes with six stainless steel trays, providing ample drying space for all your dehydration needs.

When selecting a dehydrator, the quantity of food you plan to dehydrate simultaneously should be taken into account. If you plan to dehydrate large batches of food, a machine with more trays, like the Magic Mill, would be more suitable.

The Cosori Food Dehydrator, with its six trays, is perfect for smaller batches or for those with limited storage space, such as when using a Taylor Sahara folding table.

Temperature Range and Control

A wide temperature range in a food dehydrator is essential as it allows for more precise dehydration. The Magic Mill Food Dehydrator offers a temperature range of 95 to 158 degrees Fahrenheit, which is well-suited for drying a variety of foods, including herbs and meats. The Cosori Food Dehydrator takes it a step further with a versatile temperature range from 95°F to 165°F, enabling the proper drying of a wide variety of foods.

When selecting a food dehydrator, another vital factor to consider is temperature accuracy. In this aspect, the Cosori Dehydrator stands out with its exceptional temperature control, consistently maintaining a high level of accuracy with minimal variation from the set temperature.

Noise Level

The user experience can be notably influenced by the noise level of a food dehydrator. A louder dehydrator, particularly those with more powerful fans and motors, can be disruptive, especially considering that food dehydrators operate for extended periods. The Magic Mill Food Dehydrator operates at a noise level of 41 dB, while the Cosori Food Dehydrator operates at around 60+ dB, similar to that of regular conversation or background music.

The noise level of a dehydrator can be influenced by a range of factors such as:

  • the type and model of the dehydrator
  • the fan speed
  • materials and construction
  • size
  • design

Both Magic Mill and Cosori have managed to strike a balance between power and noise, offering efficient dehydration with minimal noise disruption.

Performance and Efficiency

Performance and efficiency are the ultimate metrics for any appliance, and food dehydrators are no exception. To gauge the performance and efficiency of the Magic Mill and Cosori dehydrators, a comprehensive set of tests were conducted, including the dehydration of herbs, production of beef jerky, and fruit leather.

Despite the scientific rigour of these tests, the end product’s quality is subjective. Therefore, a panel of tasters evaluated the final products from both dehydrators, including:

  • fruit leather
  • tomatoes
  • herbs
  • beef jerky

The products were evaluated in terms of texture, evenness, and flavor.

Fruit Leather Test

Fruit leather is a popular snack made by pureeing and drying fruit, and it’s an excellent test for any food dehydrator. During the fruit leather test, the procedures outlined by The National Center for Home Food Preservation were adhered to, involving the pureeing of strawberries with lemon juice to create fruit leathers.

The estimated duration for the dehydration process of fruit leather in both the Magic Mill and Cosori Food Dehydrators is typically 6-8 hours at a temperature of 145F/63C.

The consistency of the fruit leather produced in the Cosori Food Dehydrator using fruit roll sheets is soft and chewy, a desirable quality for fruit leather.

Beef Jerky Test

Beef jerky is a classic snack made by dehydrating thin slices of beef. The recommended duration for drying beef jerky in a dehydrator is typically between 4-6 hours at 160°F.

Both the Magic Mill and Cosori Food Dehydrators demonstrate strong performance when utilized for making beef jerky, producing a product with a resilient and chewy texture, being firm and pliable rather than brittle, and a rich and savory taste.

Vegetable and Herb Test

Vegetables and herbs are another excellent test for any food dehydrator. The recommended temperature range for drying vegetables in the Magic Mill Food Dehydrator is 95 to 158°F, with a maximum drying time of 24 hours in half-hour increments.

The quality of dried vegetables and herbs can be evaluated by regularly monitoring the drying process and observing the texture to ensure the complete removal of moisture. The Magic Mill Food Dehydrator has a reputation for consistently producing excellent dried herbs, making it an excellent choice for herb enthusiasts.

Ease of Use and Cleaning

When it comes to kitchen appliances, ease of use and cleaning can significantly impact the user experience. Some factors that make the Magic Mill and Cosori dehydrators a delight to use are:

  • User-friendly interface
  • Comprehensive control panels
  • Timers
  • Automatic shut-off functions
  • Easy maintenance

The tray design greatly affects the user experience. Dehydrators with larger tray spaces allow for dehydrating more food simultaneously, thus improving the overall usability. Furthermore, maintaining a clean food dehydrator is essential due to the potential buildup of food residue on trays and interior surfaces. Therefore, choosing a model that facilitates easy cleaning like the Magic Mill and Cosori dehydrators is crucial.

User Interface

Both the Magic Mill and Cosori dehydrators feature a modern digital interface, providing controls for time and temperature adjustments. These attributes empower users to confidently configure the machine before work or bedtime, eliminating concerns about food spoilage.

Users commonly express satisfaction with the user-friendly operation of both the Magic Mill and Cosori dehydrators. The Cosori Dehydrator, in particular, is delivered fully assembled and includes a digital control panel that is designed to be intuitive and easy to use, prioritizing convenience and user-friendliness.

Tray Design and Cleaning

The Magic Mill Dehydrator includes both mesh and nonstick trays to accommodate a wide range of foods, while the Cosori Dehydrator comes with easy-to-clean plastic trays. The design of these trays affects not only the cooking capacities but also the ease of food loading and arrangement.

Dishwasher-safe trays are recommended for easy cleaning. Both Magic Mill and Cosori dehydrators have dishwasher-safe trays, making the cleaning process a breeze. This easy maintenance ensures the longevity of the machine and the quality and safety of dried foods.

Price and Value for Money

The Cosori Food Dehydrator is priced at $160, while the price of the Magic Mill Food Dehydrator is not available for comparison at this time. While price plays an important role when buying a food dehydrator, the machine’s features and performance should not be overlooked. A comprehensive assessment of the Cosori Dehydrator’s performance and effectiveness is necessary to ascertain whether its features are commensurate with its price.

Determining the value for money of each dehydrator can be challenging without the specific cost of the Magic Mill Dehydrator. However, consumers should assess the cost against user satisfaction, features, and performance results of the Cosori Dehydrator to determine its value. Without knowing the price of the Magic Mill Dehydrator, a fair assessment cannot be made without taking into account its value factors.

User Reviews and Feedback

User reviews and feedback offer a wealth of insight into a product’s performance and usability. For the Magic Mill Food Dehydrator, users have expressed favorable feedback about its consistent delivery of perfect jerky, dried fruit, and herbs. However, some users have reported a potent plastic odor during unboxing and initial usage, inconsistent dehydration due to uneven heat distribution, and problems with the fan.

The Cosori Food Dehydrator has received positive feedback for its:

  • Convenient and noiseless dehydrating process
  • 6-tray unit
  • Automatic timer
  • Adjustable thermostat

These user reviews provide a glimpse into the real-world performance of these dehydrators, helping potential buyers make an informed decision.

Pros and Cons

Despite both Magic Mill and Cosori food dehydrators offering high-quality dehydrated foods, user-friendly operation, easy maintenance, adjustable timer and temperature control, and versatility, they each present a unique set of benefits and drawbacks.

The Magic Mill Food Dehydrator offers high-quality dehydrated foods, a compact size, user-friendly operation, and even drying of food. However, it also comes with its set of challenges, such as uneven heat distribution leading to inconsistent dehydration and potential fan malfunctions.

On the other hand, the Cosori Food Dehydrator is known for its quiet operation, stylish design, and easy-to-use digital control panel. However, the specific pros and cons of the Cosori food dehydrator were not specified in the provided information and may require further review of user feedback or additional sources for clarification.


In the arena of food dehydrators, both the Magic Mill and Cosori models make a strong case for being your next kitchen companion. Both offer a robust set of features, with the Magic Mill standing out for its even drying and the Cosori for its easy-to-use digital control panel and quiet operation. However, choosing one over the other ultimately depends on your specific needs and preferences.

With the information provided in this article, you are now better equipped to make an informed decision. Remember, the journey towards healthier and more sustainable living starts one step at a time, and investing in a food dehydrator could be that first step.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Cosori a good brand for dehydrator?

Cosori dehydrators have been praised for being easy and fun to use, making them a great choice for beginners. Reviews support this, providing evidence that Cosori is a great brand of dehydrators.

What is the best first time dehydrator?

For a first time dehydrator, the Presto Dehydro Square Dehydrator 06304 is a great choice for its simple yet effective design and two fine-mesh inserts and two fruit leather drying trays. Alternatively, if you are looking for a higher performing model, we recommend the Magic Mill Food Dehydrator.

Who makes the best jerky dehydrator?

The Excalibur Food Dehydrator is the best option for making jerky, according to consumer reviews. It’s efficient, reliable, and powerful enough to produce the best results.

What is a food dehydrator, and what is it used for?

A food dehydrator is a useful tool that helps extract moisture from food, allowing users to create items like jerky and fruit leather for preservation purposes.

What are the main features of a food dehydrator?

A food dehydrator is characterized by the number of trays it has, its drying capacity, temperature range and control, and noise level.

author avatar
Hey there, since 2016, my mission has been to provide you with the information and guides you need to make food dehydrating simple and fun. Whether you're a newbie or a seasoned pro, my site offers helpful guides, reviews, and recipes to enhance your dehydrating experience. I take pride in only recommending products I believe in, ensuring my readers' trust. As an affiliate of various programs, including Amazon Associates, your support helps me continue providing quality content. Thanks for stopping by, and happy dehydrating!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *